Over the years, debates have bordered on which golf club iron is the best between forged irons and cast irons due to the correlating characteristics of these two types of club irons. Besides, most used irons clubs are made from the forged process, while game development irons are produced from cast process. However, golfers with in-depth knowledge about the unique characteristics and manufacturing process will have a better understanding of the relationship between forged and cast irons.
Differences Between Forged and Cast Irons
- It’s a hard fragment of metal in its raw state;
- It goes through intense heat and is beaten into the right form and loft;
- It results in having fewer air bubbles and optimizes distance control, thereby guaranteeing improved consistency;
- When hitting, it gives a better feel and vibration;
- Approximately 10% of iron clubs are forged;
- It is often used in players irons;
- It’s more complicated process makes it more expensive.
- Liquid metal in its raw state;
- Shape using a mold;
- Other components like extra weight and creative cavities, could be inserted;
- Less feel due to louder vibration;
- Up to 90% of Iron clubs produced from the casting process;
- Typically used to improve golfers game;
- More straightforward process and usually less expensive.
What Irons Should I Buy?
Though the need of golfers varies, generally for those seeking to optimize feel and control, you should purchase forged irons while golfers with a low budget looking to buy a durable iron set with enhancing distance should opt for cast irons.
It is important to note that above generalization has a specific exception, and deciding which features are uniquely relevant to you is the best way to make a more informed decision.
Here are various characteristics of iron clubs and the effect of the production process(cast or forged).
FEEL: Although forged irons assure better feel and sound at impact due to its more compact club shape and weight positioning concentrated behind the center of the club. Cast also irons feel great as well.
DISTANCE: The manufacturing processes both the cast and forged irons do not impact the range of a ball. Though the lofts of the forged irons are weaker, compare to cast irons. Any iron of the same degree (cast or forged) will go the similar distance.
DURABILITY AND MAINTENANCE: Forged golf clubs require more maintenance to protect against wear like rust, and discolored impact spot compared to cast irons.
Forged irons are softer and also need periodic checks on lofts and lies to ensure it hasn’t shifted.
DISTANCE CONTROL: Both production processes do not affect shots or impact, except it is a flaw. Fault such as tiny air bubble could lead to a tad improve in distance control. The forged irons with more compacted metal design often lead to superior distance controls, which are barely noticeable.
FORGIVENESS: The sole design and perimeter weighting are the primary sources of mercy, definitely not how the clubs manufacturing process. However, the cast irons are game improvement irons which offer more forgiveness compare to forged irons.
LAUNCH ANGLE/TRAJECTORY/SPIN: These are not influenced by the production process, but by the weight placement, loft, and groove placement/depth.
Common Misconception about Forged Irons and Cast Irons
Forged Irons Are Designed For Better Golfers Only
This above statement is not a valid assumption. Forged irons are designed for any skill level golfer seeking improved sound and optimize feel, also, to enhance distance control.
I’ve seen lots of beginners using forged irons, likewise, many Pro golfers playing with cast clubs.
You Can Only Become So Excellent Using Cast Irons
This assumption is wrong; because various brands manufactured lots of unique cast iron sets for Pro golfers. Many cast irons offer similar or even better feel, and distance control compared forged irons.
Some professional players have not ever used a forged iron either due to loyalty to a particular brand or comfortability with cast iron feels at impact. It all boils down to individual preference.
Cast Iron Clubs Feel Bad At Impact
Not true. Lots of improvements in the manufacturing process in recent time now afford golfers the choice to purchase cast irons with the soft feeling, and forged irons with hard feelings.
Though feel is often ascertained by the sound and vibration that disperse to our hands upon every swing, which is difficult to quantify, however, the forged iron can boast of better feel compared to the cast irons.
The Best Forged Irons
Best Cheap Forged Iron Club: Wilson Staff FG Tour V6
This Wilson model is the best budget forged irons I’d recommend for any golfer (particularly Entry Level). This clubs is the ideal mix of price and forgiveness, and it guarantees to enhance feel at impact. Though not the same quality when compared to other forged irons below, this forged iron offers enough feature to take golfers game to the next level.
The Best Value Forged Iron Club: Callaway Apex Pro
This Callaway brand is a great club that offers top value at an affordable price tag for golfers in need of better feel. This club is an excellent mix of price, distance, and feel.
Though a bit less forgiving than the Wilson listed above, Apex Pro is a very long iron with stronger lofts. This club assures great distance and feels after every swing.
The Overall Best Forged Irons: TaylorMade 2018 P790
Players who want the best not minding the price tag should try these forged irons. These irons are the perfect mix of distance, appearance, and feel.
These sleek and sexy compact irons offer to improve feel and feedback and will take your game to the next level.
The Best Cast Irons
Best Low-Price Cast Irons: Wilson Staff D200
These irons are the best for low budget golfers, and this great club offers enough forgiveness for any golfer to start up his game.
Although not the best aesthetic look and a bit bulky, it makes up with longer shots and more forgiveness. Golfers seeking a better club, you’d have to spend a little more.
I’d recommend this iron for not too good ball striker.
The Best Budget Cast Irons: Cleveland CBX Launcher
Cleveland irons are one of the most underrated in the golf industry. The Cleveland CBX Launcher irons’ outstanding forgiveness will take any better ball striker game to the next level. These irons also guarantee better feel and control, while the perimeter weighting help increases better launch angle for improving ball flight.
CBX Launcher costing below $1,000 is an excellent value set when compared to the TaylorMade below.
The Overall Best Cast Iron: TaylorMade M4
TaylorMade M4 club is the best premium cast iron for golfers who can afford it. This club not only excels in distance and forgiveness but also offer incredible feel too. It is one of the most sought irons this year; not only longer but boasts of better features when compared to other irons.
M4 also improves game results for golfers who struggle to hit the ball accurately; a great club if you can afford it.
It’s the best time to ask questions and give us your feedback in comments.